Thread:KusaNin/@comment-38309233-20190817085048/@comment-25156300-20190817154823

The main issue I see is just the alien planet aspect. From the info I've read so far, your story could technically function as a separate nation to the canon ones (possibly even on another continent off the mainland). This would give a similar seclusion to the canon story without fully separating from it like a planet would. Differing cultures, politics, etc. could easily work in such a location. There could be multiple villages located on this new continent to allow more diversity for your story.

Besides this detail, the story is fine. However, a different planet still seems to lean towards AU. I'm going to check with another admin to see how they would rule it. If they are fine with it, then you are free to leave your story as it is.